I think that their personalities and looks combined are much better than the two guys in Twilight, because they are more mature. He is obviously more mature than Peeta that needs to be fed soup when he is hurt. In conclusion, Twilight is better than The Hunger Games because Bella is both a role model and someone to relate to. She stands up for herself for being be a human with faults. She over comes everything that is thrown at her. Even though sometimes she cant make decisions she eventually comes to an answer.
She stand up for the people she loves when the Vulitori attacks and when her own husband wants to abort her child. She ends up with everything she wanted because she worked and fought for it. She goes through rough patches with friends and she learns to salvage all her relationships.
The plot of twilight is better because the whole series isn't about one thing like hunger games the games. Twilight has so many characters that makes the whole plot interesting.
Jacob and Edward care about Bella and that is why they fight for her. Peeta and Gale just sit back and wait for Katniss to make a decision. Twilight has very different well rounded characters that make us the story and a plot the never gets boring or strays from a meaning of our reality without vampires and ware wolfs.
Report this Argument Con Age is just a number, it doesn't necessarily reflect a person's measure of maturity. The fact that Peeta was injured and needed help eating, has nothing to do with his maturity level. Regardless, I believe that the Hunger Games are much more entertaining than Twilight. The story behind the Hunger Games has many different aspects to it, it's not just about one thing, and it draws fans from all age groups. It includes something for everyone, ranging from friendship, family loyalty, politics, action, and sacrifice, to love.
According to a survey, Hollywood Lifers , the majority of Twilight fans are only made up of two types of people. One being, the nerdy girl who thinks that the school hunk ignores her because he's secretly in love with her, and two, her mother, who is saddened by the lack of passion in her marriage, so she writes an amorous fan fiction revolving around Edward and Bella.
She also embarks on dangerous adventures where she might possibly lose her life to get brief glimpses of Edward. Pretty messed up. Everyone knows that Bella always tended to be the damsel in distress throughout the Twilight saga but in The Hunger Games saga, Katniss was far from a damsel in distress.
In fact, she was the one who typically had to do the rescuing when it came to Peeta who always seemed to get caught up in some sort of trouble.
Kudos to her for being a strong and empowered woman who doesn't need to be saved It wasn't very even. Bella always ultimately knew she'd end up with Edward if she had it her way. So why on earth would she be so willing to lead poor Jacob on for so long?
Many fans believe she should have chosen Jacob over Edward! Jacob's feelings for her were so genuine and pure because he only wanted to see her happy and safe.
If she'd chosen Jacob, she would have been able to grow old with him and feel his warmth. Instead, she chose Edward who was ice cold to the touch and technically, already dead. The fact that Gale and Katniss' only real bonding scene in The Hunger Games movie franchise was when they went hunting together is beyond cringe-worthy and unfortunate. This enormous stress shows us another aspect of The Hunger Games. Because of their dire situation and because so many people depend on their success, the main characters grow.
They change. They become better and stronger people because of the trials they go through. This is true for many people who may have read and may read these books. We all make mistakes, and, whether or not we like it, we learn and grow from those mistakes. On the other hand, we have Twilight, in which the main antagonist is the Volturi. As compared with President Snow, the Volturi are not much of a threat.
Where President Snow is willing to do anything to keep his power which is a human reaction , the Volturi already know that their victory is secured. In the world of Twilight, none of the vampires, the only beings that could stand up to the Volturi, do. The Volturi are not human, and therefore do not feel the pressure of having to suppress the vampires, which means that their threat is not as immediate, and therefore not as dangerous, unlike President Snow in The Hunger Games.
Something that makes Twilight relatable to fans today is that the time period is current. While this is relatable to many people, it does not disguise anything, which basically means that this series has nothing to do with the important issues of mankind.
The story is all about Bella and Edward. The situations the characters find themselves in in The Hunger Games involve the whole country, which makes it more important that the characters do the right thing, whereas the choices of the characters in Twilight only matter to themselves. Alluring to Twilight fans is that the love interest of the main character who is human, like them is a vampire. A tall, handsome, mysterious, dangerous vampire. Because of the similarities between themselves and the main character, women who read the Twilight series get to fall in love with the perfect man right alongside Bella.
Bella is essentially a faceless place holder, a shell that women of this day can project themselves onto to fulfill their own fantasies of being desired by the perfect lover. Where Bella is a flat character, Katniss is a robust, strong character.
She has something important to fight for, socially and politically significant decisions to make, and she goes through trials that expand her character. While Twilight is basically a fantasy romance, The Hunger Games is a serious look at political suppression and individual choice and accountability. The last, and perhaps most alluring factor of Twilight, is the romance, more specifically the love triangle between Bella, Edward, and Jacob.
Jacob is also pouty, but that is understandable because of his condition. The last point, while oddly sweet. Love is a universal concept and plays an important role in both stories.
The Hunger Games also shows different kinds of love, other than between a boy and a girl; Katniss is extremely close to her sister, Prim; Katniss and Gale are best friends, although we later find out that Gale has feelings for Katniss; although reluctant, Katniss loves her mom or at least trusts her not to disappear on Prim again , which could be relatable to many teenagers of this day; Cinna helps Katniss survive in the arena as best he can, for which Katniss loves him.
In Twilight, we understand that the Cullens love each other with sibling-like love between the couples, anyway , and we understand that Bella loves her mother and father, but those relationships are only mentioned in fleeting glances. The majority of the series is spent on Bella and Edward whose attentions are spent all on themselves. In both series, the main character and narrator is a girl, which at least for me helps connect audiences to the story, especially since both stories are written for teenage girls.
Those circumstances are real today: think about conflicts going on in Somalia and other African countries, China, the Middle East, and other places around the world. On the other hand, Twilight is just about the main character and her love Bella and Edward , so the males who read the Twilight series probably only read it so they can understand what their girlfriends are babbling about.
The Hunger Games is a series read and enjoyed by all, not just girls. For both stories, the heroines have skills necessary to survive; Katniss is a tough hunter, but is capable of love, which she demonstrates with Prim, Gale, Rue, and Peeta. Bella is responsible and adjusts quickly but then, so does Katniss. The Volturi are only really concerned with Bella and her party, which makes me wonder what Bella would do if they threatened all of Forks?
Or all of Washington? Error We are having trouble saving your comment. Please try again. Next Article Tags: Stephenie Meyer , teen fiction , yound adults , romance fantasy , Suzanne Collins , dystopian future. Start a Debate Would you like to create a debate and share it with the netivist community? Start a debate. Found a technical issue? Are you experiencing any technical problem with netivist?
Please let us know! Tell me more. Help netivist Help netivist continue running free! Follow us on social media:. Your name. Your email. You can type multiple email addresses separated by commas. Close Send. Submit to Reddit. Share on Facebook. Share on Twitter. Share on Pinterest.
0コメント